The Shocking Twist in Trump’s Tariff War—Is His Trade Agenda Over?

In 2018, when then-President Donald Trump declared a sweeping tariff hike on Chinese goods, it didn’t feel like just a policy move—it felt like a declaration of war. The U.S. had long grumbled about trade deficits and intellectual property theft, but Trump turned frustration into fiery action. He slapped tariffs on steel, aluminum, washing machines, and hundreds of billions worth of Chinese exports.

For Trump’s supporters, it was a moment of reckoning—finally, a president who stood up to China. For critics, it was a reckless economic gamble that invited retaliation and chaos.

Among the first to feel the impact was a soybean farmer in Iowa, Dale Johnson. “China was my biggest customer,” he recalls. “Almost overnight, that disappeared. I had to burn through my savings just to stay afloat.”
Johnson’s story was echoed across America’s heartland—where industries reliant on exports faced punishing consequences.
Trump’s tariffs didn’t just hurt China—they boomeranged. Costs rose for American manufacturers who depended on Chinese parts. Harley-Davidson shifted some production overseas. GM closed plants. Retailers braced for higher prices, and consumers eventually paid more.
But Trump remained undeterred. “Trade wars are good, and easy to win,” he famously said.

Yet the scoreboard suggested otherwise.

By 2020, the trade deficit with China had barely budged. And when COVID-19 struck, global trade slowed down, making the chaos of tariffs seem almost quaint in comparison. For a time, it looked like Trump’s trade war had fizzled into just another chapter of his unconventional presidency.
But now, in 2025, as he gears up for a possible return to the White House, Trump’s trade war isn’t over—it’s evolving.
“I will impose a universal 10% tariff on all imports,” Trump declared at a campaign rally in Ohio this year, his fist clenched, the crowd roaring. “And a 60% tariff on Chinese goods.”

The announcement sent shockwaves through markets. Economists, foreign leaders, and American CEOs alike were stunned—not because Trump was proposing tariffs, but because the scale of his plan made the 2018 version look modest.

If implemented, Trump’s new tariff strategy could disrupt global supply chains, inflate prices, and invite swift retaliation. But for Trump, it’s a familiar card—one he knows plays well with his base.

“He’s not just running on immigration anymore,” says political analyst Carla Montes. “Trade is his new hammer. And he’s swinging it hard.”
Trump’s tariff agenda is not just about economics—it’s deeply political. It taps into a widespread sentiment among working-class Americans that globalization left them behind.

For many, like Sharon Wiley, a former textile worker in North Carolina, the pain of outsourcing still lingers. “My factory shut down in 2008. The jobs went to Mexico, then China. Trump’s the only one who made me feel seen.”

It’s this emotional resonance that gives Trump’s trade rhetoric power. To his supporters, tariffs symbolize fairness, justice, and America-first grit. To critics, it’s economic nationalism dressed up as policy.

President Biden, by contrast, has taken a more measured approach—retaining some of Trump’s tariffs, negotiating others, and focusing on strategic alliances. Yet, the Biden administration has struggled to communicate a cohesive trade vision that resonates emotionally the way Trump’s does.
Trump’s aggressive tariff pitch is causing a rift—not just internationally, but within America itself.

Corporate America is nervous. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, tech giants, and auto manufacturers have warned that a 10% universal tariff would lead to inflation, job cuts, and supply chain disruptions.

“Tariffs are taxes—plain and simple,” says Martin Greene, a senior executive at a Fortune 500 retailer. “And guess who pays them? American families.”

But on Main Street, the message lands differently.

“We’re tired of being the world's discount mall,” says Randy Mendoza, a small factory owner in Ohio. “If tariffs mean bringing jobs back, then bring them on.”

This tension between Wall Street’s data and Main Street’s desperation is central to the Trump trade twist. One sees cost; the other sees dignity.
Beijing isn’t sitting idle. In response to Trump’s tariff threats, China has signaled countermeasures, including potential bans on American agricultural goods and tech products.

“Trump’s threats destabilize global trade,” Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Liu Ping said in a recent press briefing. “We urge the U.S. to act responsibly.”

But Trump thrives on provocation. And unlike in 2018, China in 2025 is more assertive, more decoupled, and less vulnerable to U.S. pressure. The Chinese economy, though slowing, has diversified its trade partnerships, and its Belt and Road Initiative has built stronger ties with emerging economies.
If Trump returns with an even harsher trade policy, the global economic order could shift dramatically.

The European Union has already hinted at retaliatory tariffs if the U.S. disrupts trade norms. Developing nations fear collateral damage in global supply chains. And the World Trade Organization—largely sidelined during Trump’s first term—may find itself in an existential crisis.

“It’s not just about U.S. and China anymore,” says trade lawyer Anika Rao. “A Trump trade war 2.0 would be a worldwide tremor.”
Some experts believe Trump’s tariff talk is more bark than bite.

“Trump uses tariffs as leverage,” says economist Dan Eisner. “He throws out big numbers to get countries to the table. But when it comes time to govern, the policies often get watered down.”

This bluff theory isn’t without precedent. The 2020 U.S.-China “Phase One” deal ended up with China committing to buy more U.S. goods—promises it partially fulfilled—but much of the structural imbalance remained.

Still, others warn against underestimating him.

“Trump doesn’t bluff on things that galvanize his base,” says Montes. “And tariffs are red meat.”
President Biden has responded to Trump’s resurgence with a hybrid approach: defending American manufacturing, investing in chip production, and courting allies through trade pacts.

But it lacks the punch and clarity of Trump’s tariff war.

“I’m not sure what Biden’s trade strategy is,” says Johnson, the soybean farmer from Iowa. “I just know things are still tough.”

This policy opacity may be Biden’s Achilles heel. In an election season fueled by economic anxiety, simplicity sells—and Trump’s message is as blunt as it is bold: Tariffs = American Jobs.

If Trump returns in 2025 and follows through on his 10% blanket tariff and 60% China-specific tariff, the economic consequences could be severe. The Peterson Institute estimates it could cost the average American household $1,700 annually. Inflation could spike. Supply chains would scramble again.

But Trump’s pitch isn't about cost—it's about symbolism.

He frames tariffs as patriotic, as a way to stand up to bullies, protect jobs, and assert U.S. independence. And for millions, that message matters more than the spreadsheets.
While the numbers dominate headlines, the real stories lie in homes and towns across America.

• In Detroit, a laid-off autoworker hopes tariffs will bring her job back.
• In Los Angeles, a tech startup worries about losing access to cheap semiconductors.
• In Arkansas, a poultry farmer prays that China won’t block exports again.

These lives hang in the balance—not of an abstract “trade policy,” but of a political gamble playing out on the world stage.

And yet, amid all the chaos and rhetoric, there's hope. Hope that real, nuanced trade reform—balancing fairness and globalization—can rise above the binary of war and peace.

So, is Trump’s trade agenda over?

Far from it. In fact, it may be entering its most aggressive phase yet.

But it’s no longer just about China or steel or soybeans. It’s about the soul of America’s economic identity—how it sees itself in a globalized world, and how it chooses to fight for its place.

For Trump, tariffs are more than a tool—they’re a brand. A battle cry. A promise.

Whether that promise brings prosperity or pain remains to be seen.

One thing is clear: the trade war isn’t just back—it’s personal.

Unlock insightful tips and inspiration on personal growth, productivity, and well-being. Stay motivated and updated with the latest at My Life XP.